I've been pondering this one for a while:
For those of you who are married or who've been married:
Why did you get married? Did it change your (primary) relationship to be married? How? (For those of you who are nonmonogamous, did it change your other relationships?)
Is marriage what you expected? How? How not? Is it what you hoped? Is it harder/easier?
If you could go back and give your pre-marriage self some advice or insight, what would it be?
Anonymous posting is (always) on.
For those of you who are married or who've been married:
Why did you get married? Did it change your (primary) relationship to be married? How? (For those of you who are nonmonogamous, did it change your other relationships?)
Is marriage what you expected? How? How not? Is it what you hoped? Is it harder/easier?
If you could go back and give your pre-marriage self some advice or insight, what would it be?
Anonymous posting is (always) on.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 02:18 am (UTC)My whole life I was told " this will go under your wedding cake" when my mom bought a certain piece of lace, or "this would be a great place for your wedding" when we would visit a park.
I was one of those girls that NEVER dreamed about her wedding day. It was something I never thought about, just assumed that it would be done.
It was done solely for my parents. They wanted it so badly. I couldn't have cared less.
It didn't change our relationship at all. As a matter of fact, soon after we split because I wanted to live in the mountains, and he wanted to stay in the city. We would visit on weekends.
It really meant nothing but a party for my parents. They were big on parties.
Now I am not married but in a committed relationship that is a marriage to me without the ceremony. Since I don't care what my family/ friends/neighbors think about us, I have no interest in "declaring" in front of them. It's none of their business.
Weddings are my worst nightmare.
A couple of good friends, people I introduced, got married 4 years ago. I was asked to be a brides maid. I had a lot of problems with this. I aked her why did she want this? I did it.
I just might not have the wedding gene, because I really hate anything to do with weddings and marriage.
Maybe because I am such a private person, I just think this most intimate relationship is no one elses business. Or another convention I won't let society force on me.
Maybe this post is more about weddings than marriage, but what is a marriage without a wedding? I mean it is the catalyst.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 12:15 pm (UTC)Now I am not married but in a committed relationship that is a marriage to me without the ceremony.
Now that has a lot of appeal.
Unlike you, however, I like weddings. I've only been to one that I knew right off the bat wasn't going to work, and I was GLAD it wasn't going to work, and I was also glad they were doing the legal thing because of some protections it would bring my friend and her kids. In general, though I don't think it's the right thing for me, I enjoy the big parties people throw, and I like to celebrate their love with them. I get a little prickly when their vows say things like, "I promise you my undying love," because it seems foolish to promise something you can't guarantee, but when they say, "We're committing to work to make a happy life together, through thick and thin," I at least feel like they're being realistic.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 07:34 pm (UTC)I have been to 5 weddings since I have been living in this town, and only 3 of the couples are still married. One couple was 18 when they married so even though they have been married 1 1/2 years and now have a new baby, I have my doubts about them.
One of the couples are an older couple ( 50's) I think that one is good.
The other are my friends. It looks good for them so far.
I can't go to a wedding without this on my mind.
I'm all "yeah, right" during the ceremony..
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-13 03:18 am (UTC)isn't that an eerie feeling? i had that experience a few years ago, and slowly watched my friend and her husband destroy each other over the next few years. thankfully, she finally pulled out about a year ago and is becoming human again, slowly. yeccchh.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-13 03:11 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-14 12:13 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-13 03:23 pm (UTC)rosa, i'm not sure if you'd want me to answer this since i've never been legally married.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-13 03:24 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 02:21 am (UTC)> some advice or insight, what would it be?
Have a pre-nuptial agreement. I would give this advice
in the strongest possible terms to *anyone* who's thinking
about getting married, and not just on the grounds that
your spouse might go psycho. There are a lot of other
good reasons:
a) If you ever should break up---and let's face it, you
might---then your children, your property, and the extent
to which your lives remain entangled will be determined by
the laws of your state. These laws will be written by the
same state legislators who today are busy proscribing gay
marriage and (at least in my state) banning the little
clicky things that keep the gas pump running while you
go in to buy a candy bar. These are *not* the people who
should be running your life, and it's important to take a
stand to that effect. Each pre-nup is a statement that
state legislators ought not be telling people how to run
their families.
b) Even if you're perfectly happy with the laws of your
state, they are subject to change at any moment. By not
having a pre-nup you make yourselves vulnerable to any
nutty idea any state legislator comes up with over the
next several decades. Plus, to repeat myself, it's
important to make the statement that these guys have no
business telling you how to run your life, even if they're
currently telling you how to run it the way you want to
anyway.
c) In negotiating a pre-nup you're going to be
negotiating a lot of important issues that you really
ought to be thinking hard about before you get married
anyway. E.g: Is everything share and share alike, or
are we each going to have some money that's ours alone?
If one of us decides to take some time off work, do we
expect the other to pick up all the financial slack, and
if so, under what circumstances would this be considered
exploitative, etc etc. If you're going to live together
you'd better get this stuff straight. If you're going to
get it straight, you might as well write it down.
d) Expanding on c), the Nobel laureate George Stigler
once said that he was appalled by people who so
denigrated the great institution of marriage that they
couldn't even be bothered to negotiate the details. Amen.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 12:18 pm (UTC)However, I'm very critical of the legal institution of marriage, and looking at pre-nuptual agreements as a way of taking control of something that the government shouldn't have control of in the first place is a very compelling argument.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 09:52 pm (UTC)You asked why people got married, not why they didn't, but I know both questions interest you, so I'll tell you my reason. Technically, I have a whole range of reasons for not anticipating a marriage in my life. But the biggest reason is that I can't imagine knowing that I would want to be someone's partner for the rest of my life. I can imagine knowing that I would want to be their partner now, and for the foreseeable future. But, for the rest of my life? Forever? Till death do us part? How do I know what's going to happen to me, or to the other person, in the future? How can I know how either of us will change? When I was 18, I never would have imagined that I would want the things I want now that I'm 28. So how can I say that I know now what I will want when I'm 38, or 48? I don't ever want to say to a person, "I want to be with you forever," unless I'm sure it's true. And how can I be sure?
This being said, I am a romantic at heart, in that I believe I could find someone I'd spend my whole life with. I just don't think that at any point during that life, I could be sure about what lay ahead. Not until I'm on my deathbed, and could look back, and smile at the nice thing that happened.
Eomer is the only exception. I would marry Eomer. :-)
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-13 12:43 am (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 03:32 am (UTC)I don't think it really changed our relationship. The decision to *get* married did, somewhat. It made already-existing ideas more definite in my head. Is it what I expected? ...er, I guess? I didn't know quite what I expected, and it's turned out well, and that's generally how I hope gigantic projects will go. :) I suppose it might be easier than I'd feared it would be, since people were always talking about how much marriage changes relationships and then when it didn't, I was relieved.
We didn't have any other relationships before marriage, but I think that for me (and for D, chiming in across the room), being married makes polyamory easier and less scary.
I like my marriage. Yup.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 12:19 pm (UTC)I like my marriage. Yup.
Yay :)
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 02:07 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 04:09 am (UTC)I got married the second time because Orin wanted us to, and I did wind up kind of getting carried away with the romance of it all. Also, wanted kid.
First time, it didn't change our relationship as far as I recall. We were only together and married for a year, and we separated - wow - 11 years ago. The second time, it didn't change our relationship, but it did make it last longer, because we were more invested in it. I'm not sure this was a good thing, since it also prolonged the misery. It didn't change my other relationships except once in a while someone had an issue with dating a "married woman."
Marriage was much harder than I expected, but then I married two men who were unsuitable for me. From speaking to my happily married friends, it appears to be a lot of work, but not too difficult.
I have vowed never to get legally married again. There is no way I am going to promise to be devoted to one person forever and ever. Who knows how I will change or he will change? I'd be cool with commitments of a certain number of years, like one to five. But my whole life? No way. The only person I stand by no matter what is my daughter.
I don't even like attending weddings or watching them on TV, because it just seems like such a Bad Idea to me. I also recognize that this is my own baggage and maybe someday it'll change.
I would tell my pre-marriage self that wanting to have a baby is a bad reason to get married, and also that marriage in and of itself makes no sense, when chances are you won't stay together forever. Of course, this would make Ilana *POOF* out of existence, so I guess I wouldn't do it. I guess then I would tell my pre-marriage self to insist on keeping the finances separate, because money was the main thing Orin and I fought about.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 12:24 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 04:17 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 04:24 am (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 04:41 am (UTC)it's ironic, for me the biggest change isn't the rings or the official document somewhere in a city of somerville folder; it's the memory of the october afternoon, and all the people we had there who witnessed it and signed their names to our certificate. any time we've had a difficulty that might have turned into trouble, i have thought of that and have said to myself, "we -must- work through this." and so far, we always have.
i suspect i'd have lots of advice to give myself, but then i tend to be a bit over-analytical in that way, and i also tend to not listen to advice; so it makes no sense to try to have given myself any. or something like that. :)
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 04:42 am (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 05:30 am (UTC)The second time---I love my Kitsune so much, and our wedding was super fun, etc., but as I get older the less I think that I believe in marriage for me. I get awfully cranky now and again, having to put up with another person living in the same house. We were registered at domestic partners, so there was no legal/financial difference in getting married---it was largely that it was very important for him. And that's fine, unless he starts to get upset about my crankiness.
Marriage was harder than I expected the first time around, but I think that is mostly b/c he was a philandering, abusive, alcholic. This time around, it's easier than I expected, because Kitsune treats me like a grownup.
If I could go back to my pre-married self, my advice would be "wait." I was not mature at 23, and that's awfully young to get married anyhow. I could really have used some years to sort myself out.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 04:20 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 04:32 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 05:26 pm (UTC)(And yes: I'm female.)
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 01:00 pm (UTC)I don't think there is anything I would tell my pre-married self except perhaps a prenuptual agreement is a good thing. That's a tough one, it *is* a good idea, but so is faith. If I were to ever marry again though, I would definatley have one as the kids and their financial future is at stake.
marriage
Date: 2005-04-12 01:30 pm (UTC)Then I was a dyke and had a LOT of anger about heterosexual privledge.
Then out of the blue I feel in love with this rude, gruff, rough around the edges, really smart man, whoops! I wanted to marry him and have kids for a long time. He did not, partly because he was coming off a marriage that do not work out. Many years later he wanted to marry and I did not. Eventually we got pregnant. During this my father was dying. It was one of my dad's last wishes that we get married. Twenty days after his death I granted his wish. I agreed to take Rick up on his really great insurance policy,which was better than the one I had.
I love being married. We did not put any forever talk into our vows because we agreed life is ever changing and so are people. Ultimately I believe Rick brings to me many of the lessons I have to learn in this life. I love being supported and love and I love giving that back every day or at least I try.
I am not sure I had a lot of expectations going into our marriage, other than love, support and clear communication. So far we are doing okay. 5.5 married, 8.5 together.
I think unfortunately being married makes our life easier because a huge part of the population "understands" the context of our relationship and therefor do not give us a hard time.
Advice for my pre-marriage self about marriage- none.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 04:18 pm (UTC)The second time I got married, I did it so that my partner could get on my insurance. I was working and he was still in school. Originally, we did the legal deed solely for the legal benefits, but over the almost-5-years that we were legally married, I think that we slid into being "married" in a suburban sort of way. Most of that time we were still living in Texas and directly because of that we weren't especially out about being bisexual and polyamorous. I feel that eventually our relationship started to take on some of the stereotypical qualities/characteristics that the average Houston suburbanite expects when they hear the word "marriage." We used that word, they thought/expected those things, eventually we started thinking/expecting some of those things. So yes, I feel that it did change our relationship, but only because of the way we dealt with it. I don't believe it *had* to change our relationship. At the times of each of my marriages, I had no other partners for the marriage to have changed.
The first time around, marriage wasn't what I expected nor what I hoped, but I went into that pretty idealistically and pretty unrealistically. The second time around, the first few years of the marriage *were* what I expected, and what we had professed to want from each other--we were best friends. The last couple of years were a downward spiral. At times throughout my second marriage was both easier and harder than I expected.
I now have a partner and we're in the process of moving in together. One of my mom's first questions was whether we were getting married (she's catholic). I had to work not to laugh when I told her no. (Her particular phrasing was something alnog the lines of whether we'd be making this a permanent arrangement, like getting married. Considering that I'm twice divorced and he's once divorced, the thought of marriage and permanent in the same sentence amused the hell out of me.) Kai and I share the opinion that if things between us are still going well in another 5 or 10 years, we can think and talk about a legal arrangement then. I see no need for a legal relationship between us. We have a committed relationship--we expect to each continue growing, and to continue growing together. From where we stand now, we see no reason to think that those are unreasonable things to expect and hope for. If it ever starts looking like either of those isn't reasonable to expect, we'll reevaluate.
I wouldn't go back and give myself advice. While some of what I've lived through hasn't been easy, it's all led me to where I am now, and I really like where I am now and who I am now.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 05:28 pm (UTC)I live in surburban Houston, and at present I'm fighting this miasma tooth and nail.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 06:35 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-12 06:35 pm (UTC)Pygment and I got married for two distinct reasons, both of which we agreed on. Pragmatically, we had decided to have children and had the experience of living with a couple who were trying to raise a kid without being legally married. We simply decided we didn't want that level of hassle. State-sanctioned marriage opens so many doors there and we decided we'd rather put our energy into our baby rather that into fighting the system. (1)
On the non-pragmatic side, for us the marriage ceremony was about commitment and life transitions. We were committed to each other and to building a life together and the marriage ceremony was a showing of that commitment. When we wrote our vows one of the things we wrote about was the act of choosing - how we chose each other, how we chose to be married and a promise to continue the work of making that choice.
Those who have written about marriage as work aren't wrong.(2) For us, part of the marriage was to celebrate the work we had done to get to that position and publicly declare our intention to continue that work as individuals as well as our intention to building a joint life from there on.
I don't think it changed our relationship much to be married. We used to tease people who asked us that. I think it did affect our other relationships, but it's hard for me to quantify precisely how. You might get better answers from the people who were dating us back then.
Marriage is about what I expected - well, except for the parenting thing, which I don't think anyone is ever truly prepared for. It's both harder and easier. I think I win being the male on this one - everyone needs "a wife", especially wives.
--wex
(1) Not to denigrate anyone who takes a different choice - more power to 'em. Just not our choice.
(2) And with due respect to those who wish they had pre-nups I have yet to meet one that a competent lawyer couldn't shred. Unless you're convinced you've got the smartest lawyer in the world drafting yours and you'll get a sympathetic judge I don't see them providing much value. YMMV, of course.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-13 04:59 am (UTC)What I didn't expect, over time, was that he and I weren't very compatible in two key areas, sexuality and communication. We moved to Australia and were very isolated, and then he fell for someone and it got exponentially harder (and worse). We opened the marriage, though I had misgivings, and what ended up happening was that the gulf between us widened past bridging. His other relationship was not a catalyst, but an accelerant. In the course of our problems, marriage was so much harder than I had ever anticipated. We got divorced, and by the time we decided to do so, it was really the only sane choice, but it was incredibly difficult and sad.
I don't really think about what I wish I could have said to myself back then, but I do think about what I've learned and how to use that knowledge to make my current relationship better. Part of it is that
For a while I thought I could take or leave marriage after the divorce. Now, though, I've come to feel that I would like to be married again. Not just because of the legal and social recognition and privileges, but because I like the idea of solemnizing a bond between myself and my partner and committing to building a life together in front of my family and friends. I like the community aspect of it. I like the romantic aspect of it, too. I also believe that marriage is what the people involved make of it, and that it's perfectly valid to not invite the state to the party.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-14 12:19 pm (UTC)sometime if you're interested, i can show you the two pictures that we have of our "legal wedding": A, me, and our solemnizer, off in a corner signing a piece of paper while others were socializing.
there are lots more pictures of the ceremony (which was moving, and fun) and the party (which was fabulous). i am very, very glad that the state had no visible presence in our wedding ceremony itself.
(no subject)
Date: 2005-04-13 03:39 pm (UTC)michele wasn't out to her family for the entire 14 years that we were together so there was no question of a wedding. ayana was out and we did talk about it but a lot of her family is homophobic and it seemed fraught so we never went ahead and planned anything. she has since had a ceremony with her current partner, which goes to show something, i'm sure.
in both cases, it was important to me to term the relationship a marriage because i wanted to indicate to the world the weight i had given to these two relationships as opposed to my other relationships. i was engaged to a third woman but we never pulled the trigger and moved it to a marriage. again, not about the ceremony but about life entanglement and what you think you are building and where you think you are in that process. i wanted my family to know that those two women were my spouses--that our relationship was the emotional if not legal equivalent of my sister's marriage to her husband and my brother's marriage to his wife.
i would not say that it changed the relationships so much as that it gave shape to what was already there. it was what i expected but then i could very much have it be what i wanted it to be. i think that some of that came from being with a same sex partner. there was no "it has to look this way" to fight against.
marriage is hard and my first one was very hard. i experienced my life as happy, but it took a lot of mental gymnastics to make that so. it is lucky that i am very strong, and that's all i need to say about that. the second time was much easier, but then there are problems about how all of that happened, too, since some of the ease may have come from my ex not telling me things i needed to know. ah well.
insight to my pre-first marriage self: it is okay to give up and say this is too hard. it is okay to leave someone.
insight to my pre-second marriage self: leopards really do not usually change their spots.
i would get married again under the right set of circumstances, i think, btw. however, i was very cautious the second time and apparently still not cautious enough so i think the caution meter is currently set very very high.
I am not married.
Date: 2005-04-23 08:35 pm (UTC)Hmmm... I know there's more, but he just crawled into bed. I think he deserves my attention... :-D